If you're reading this, then you might be the first. This blog gets less traffic than a legal border crossing in Arizona. Just kidding! Do you watch Tosh .0? I suppose I should leave the questionable material to him. I've been very busy with some writing projects recently and haven't had much opportunity to post here. Plus, I'm rethinking my whole angle. The traffic thing could be funny -- but I drive the same route every day, and there's only so many posts you can write about Neponset.
Joyce and O’Brien: Anticipations of Convergence
This essay is an analysis of the ways that James Joyce’s Araby and Tim O’Brien’s Stockings comment on the problem of retaining normative values in the face of cultural alienation. I aim to show that Joyce, in 1914, and O’Brien, in 1990, contributed narratives which effectively diagnosed moral conundrums in response to historic social forces, as well as asymptomatically anticipated the ascendancy of participatory dynamics within what Henry Jenkins calls “convergence culture.” If all of this sounds to you somehow vague and/or inflated, I also aim to show how it is (really) quite clear and/or almost unjustifiably succinct. James Joyce is notoriously enigmatic, and Araby is no exception. Tim O’Brien struggles with a famously divisive and epoch-rendering war from a postmodernist perspective that by it’s nature is lent to ambiguous interpretation. It is clear to me that if we are going to engage in a dialogue with these stories, and account for their historical disparity, then we must first establish a point of reference from which to track their relative trajectories. Ideally, we can occupy a perspective from which those trajectories are observed in fractal relation to one another, and discern a pattern that we can use to tell a larger story about the emergence of participation based production within a consumer culture.
The best, and, perhaps, most logical, points of departure for this critique are the respective settings of Araby and Stockings. Here, I refer as much to the extra-textual conditions of setting as to the inter-textual ones. Inter-textually, it is most important to acknowledge that the respective settings of the stories are essential to determining the stories’ significance. In Araby, Joyce takes great pains to paint a very bleak Dublin landscape with muddled shades of brown encroaching on “dripping gardens,” and “musty air” seeping from deathbeds and “dark odorous stables.” He focuses sharply on the squalor found in the “dark muddy lanes” and “the gauntlet of the rough tribes from the cottages.” There is no doubt that the Ireland of Araby is an oppressive environment, thus the houses on the street “[gaze] at one another with brown imperturbable faces.” Stockings, while less textually prolific with regard to setting, accomplishes an equally oppressive environment with only one word: Vietnam. Tim O’Brien relies on readers’ cognitive signification networks to ad lib the relevant properties and characteristics of the setting in response to a verbal stimulus. Vietnam was a war, and war is such a universal symbol that no further textual explication is necessary to achieve the desired effect (especially when you consider that the Vietnam war was portrayed extensively, and with unprecedented access, in the media).
More important than these, however, are the extra-textual ramifications of the settings. Not the settings per se, but the fact that both Joyce and O’Brien recognized the importance of setting, and fixed the characters of these stories within very specific and historically accurate landscapes. The writers’ acknowledgement of the settings’ importance via technical and historical detail tells us something deeper about the nature of these stories: they are socially constructed. While it may not come as a surprise that Joyce and O’Brien (one from a thoroughly industrialized Dublin and the other Congressionally ordered to war) sought to critique social conditions, it is important that we arrive logically and textually at that conclusion. Once we accept the premise that these stories are fundamentally and inextricably social narratives, we can raise the really interesting questions like how social and cultural forces have evolved to affect the consciousnesses of individuals.
Consider the pantyhose in Stockings. I mean, literally, consider the seemingly innocent factoid that the story is titled Stockings, but whenever the narrator refers to the stockings in the immediate 1st person he calls them pantyhose. For example, “I can see him wrapping his girlfriend’s pantyhose around his neck before heading out on ambush” (27). This could very well be coincidental or purely stylistic. Regardless, it addresses the fact that there are two distinct terms used to refer to the titular emblem. According to Wikipedia, sheer stockings have been popular in America since the 1920’s. It wasn’t until 1959 that “Panti-Legs” went to market as a convenient alternative to stockings, and, through the 60’s, they gained popularity as they became increasingly mass-produced. Pantyhose outsold stockings for the first time in 1970 and it has remained that way ever since. The introduction and subsequent boom of pantyhose interests corresponds with a massive feminist movement within the larger U.S. Civil Rights struggle. As more and more women were empowered to enter the workplace the demand surged for a cheap, functional, disposable alternative to stockings. It is somewhat paradoxical that a product marketed as a kind of weapon for newly empowered feminists in their struggle for equal rights was, at the same time, an instantiation of the very patriarchal environment which they sought to explode.
There is another paradox between the cultural significance of the pantyhose and the role they play within the text of Stockings, which paradox will very much help to illustrate how O’Brien is commenting on what I would call the Incorporation of Individuality – or, Individuality, Inc. – which is, then, endemic in convergence culture. As stated above, one of the appeals of pantyhose, as with any mass-produced item, was their disposability. Yet, for Henry Dobbins, “The ironies went beyond him” (27). To Dobbins, “[the stockings] gave access to a spiritual world, where things were soft and intimate, a place where he might someday take his girlfriend to live” (27). Stockings, in a concupiscent way, are very personal articles of clothing. This is why Dobbins “liked putting his nose into the nylon and [breathing] in the scent of his girlfriend’s body” (27). The intimacy of the nylons provides a gateway for his escape. Dobbins lives in a world of anonymity. He is fighting someone else’s war, in someone else’s country, and, back home, John Q. Public sees him as just another soldier – or worse, someone else’s baby killer. But, contrary to all of this, the stockings belong to his girlfriend; to a particular person, in a particular place, all of which Dobbins is attached to via his memory. In this way, his wearing of the pantyhose into ambush symbolizes a blurring of the distinction between memory and continuity, between dreams and waking life. The blurring of this distinction is also a phenomenon that aligns with the overlap of consumer/producer relations seen in convergence culture theory. This is symptomatic of the ways that consumers of popular culture “poach,” to use Henry Jenkins’ term, cultural ideologies and appropriate them for personal, pragmatic application (i.e., just as feminists did with stockings). Psychologically, it represents an extra-textual foreshadowing of the ways that the memories soldiers carry after returning home from war continue to inform their daily lives. To Dobbins, the pantyhose are the singular, in-disposable element of his entire existence. Then his girlfriend dumps him. But…“The magic doesn’t go away” (28). Apparently, his girlfriend, contra the hosiery, is disposable – or, to put it in economic terms, she is interchangeable. What has happened is that a supposedly intimate and individual product (one which is, then, only a minutely focused inset on the gargantuan map of Mass Culture) has been mass-marketed as cultural memorabilia to a gaping demographic, and has effectively robbed each woman of her “individuality” and fixed her on the conveyor belt of mass production off which she strode. The text is speaking clearly to the passivity of consumerism.
There is more to this story. Consider that the passivity invoked by Stockings is, perhaps, best exemplified by Tele-visual culture en masse – a more-or-less catatonic viewer/consumer passively ingesting images/products during his/her daily, six-hour priapismic stare at a piece of furniture. Then consider that the anti-war sentiment within America during Vietnam was primarily informed by media broadcasts on T.V. Images have an enormous capacity for sentiment, and “Like his country, too, Dobbins was drawn toward sentimentality” (27). Consider, lastly, how producers discern the steady downward trend of a market (e.g. the “functional fashion” market) that attends the conscious dilution of product novelty with product interchangeability; and consider how those producers deploy through advertising a self-aware irony that subverts that dilution, and replaces front-end consumer expectation for product novelty, with back-end consumer expectation for personal novelty. But, I digress. What is important to take away from Stockings is the idea that Mass Culture is radically and systematically stripping individuals of their individuality. I will use this idea to retroactively examine Joyce’s Araby, and then use the psychology of the main characters in each story to chart a logical extension of their behavior that will place them squarely in modern, participatory culture.
If the pantyhose are the preeminent cultural signifier in Stockings, then the rusty bicycle pump is the preeminent cultural signifier in Araby. This demonstrates the most glaring cultural contradiction between the two stories: in Stockings, the culture is historically understood as abiding under a separation of Church and State; in Araby, Catholicism was the culture. Therefore, by criticizing Catholicism, Joyce was indirectly criticizing society. *
*INTERPOLATION
Without straying too far from the text of Araby, I wish to preface the next part of my argument with the following disclaimer: I do not think that James Joyce was, or should be considered, a “social novelist.” I think he was, above all, a humanist, a philosopher, and one hell of a theologian (and – obviously, but, subsequently – a writer). The social critique provided by Araby is just one consequence of a truly gigantic theological argument about the nature of Sin and the State of the World and the meaning of Life that is sparked by this story. As this is already the sixth page of a four-page assignment, I will, in the interest of brevity, only skim the surface of the theological in order to uncover the social.
The affect of James Joyce’s decision to portray the setting in Araby in relation to the Garden of Eden is twofold: first, it signifies that religion is very much a part of the environment of Dublin. In other words, it confirms that Christianity is metonymic with culture. Because Christianity is a part of the culture, it is also a part of the characters’ consciousnesses. And because it is a part of the 1st person narrator’s consciousness, we, as readers, are invited to understand the story in Christian terms. Thus, the second affect of the Eden reference serves a juxtapositional purpose: the one-time paradise is now a sodden ash-pit. Scripturally, and textually, the most important property of the setting is one of “fallen-ness.” This is the basis for Joyce’s theological critique. In order to understand why this is important, we must look at the Christian doctrine of Sin. Once again, this is a huge task. Even within Christianity, Sin is understood in a myriad of ways. The Catholic doctrine of Sin was one of the fundamental teachings brought under siege by Martin Luther at the start of the Reformation. One thing all Christians do agree upon is that Sin (with a capital S) was a byproduct of The Fall. God, being perfect in his love, created a perfect world. According to the Logos doctrine, the creation itself is an emanation of God’s love. The Logos is the creative force of the Godhead. In this perfect world, all things return to God, and, being themselves emanations of His love, all things are whole in His love to which they continually return. I know this is confusing. That’s why there are disagreements. Regardless, man’s Genesitic eating of the forbidden fruit produced the fall, of which Sin is a byproduct. Sin is the vacuum of God’s love. It is important to stress here that nothing was created in the fall – Sin is not something “new.” A useful analogy for this concept can be found in the critique of Descartes’ Mind-Body Dichotomy. In the same way that Newton’s laws of motion and of conservation of matter showed that it is impossible for anything immaterial (i.e., the “mind”) to affect material (i.e., the “body”), it is theologically impossible for anything to be created in the fall. Sin is merely the break in the circularity of God’s love that returns to God. Desire is a love that takes as its object something other than God. Here, Joyce saw something; he saw that, in a fallen world, all love – which is fundamentally good – is tainted with desire. The question then became, for him, whether a man can go about living a meaningful life within such a reality, whether love really has any value at all.
This is where his social critique begins. The protagonist of Araby is, textually, a pawn of the powers that be (i.e., biology, society, culture, history, and religion). Araby is a story about “the loss of innocence,” though in a very specific way – viz., the protagonist’s realization as to his ineffectual ignorance of these powers. The narrator believes that he is experiencing a spiritual, rather than a sexual or material, kind of love for Mangan’s sister. This is the meaning of the convoluted, ejaculatory prayer in which the narrator “press[es] the palms of [his] hands together until they trembled, murmuring: O love! O love! many times” (35). This is also why he sees her in a holy light: “The light from the lamp opposite our door caught the white curve of her neck, lit up her hair that rested there and, falling, lit up the hand upon the railing” (35). At the culmination of the narrative he gains a specific knowledge of life, and yet this knowledge does not represent something new. Rather, it is knowledge of things that were already present, of the ways in which he was deceived; the realization that his love for Mangan’s sister does not, in fact, lead to God. He experiences his own fall and, thus, he “saw [himself] as a creature driven and derided by vanity,” and his “eyes burned with anguish and anger” (37).
To better understand the social and cultural significance of this fall, we can look to social markers within the text, as well as to the literary devices employed by Joyce throughout the story. The main such device (which, consequently, gives the story its superstructure) is irony. Irony is the measuring tape of the fallen conscience. The gross irony of Araby can be summed in one potent treasure of a symbol; the dead priest’s rusty bicycle pump. The pump is, at base, a phallic representation; one that is rusty for obvious avowal reasons. But the pejorative context of the word “rusty” elicits an ironic response when circumscribed to the priest’s own phallus. Add to that the fact that the priest is dead, and the narrator found the pump under a bush in the ash-ridden garden with a central apple tree, and you’ve got a cosmic irony befitting the fallen creation. The motif of irony runs concurrently through Araby: that the priest is deemed “charitable” for giving away his worldly possessions is ironic because priests shouldn’t place great value on material things, and giving away something of no personal value is certainly not charitable. The spiritual image of Mangan’s sister that “bore [the narrator’s] chalice safely through a throng of foes” (35) is ironic because it is the same image that propelled him toward such a similar den of foes at the bazaar; a dark, empty church, a dead priest, a rusty pump and Englishmen trying to get laid. “The Arab’s Farewell to his Steed” – which tells the story of a boy who nearly trades his horse for gold but realizes at the last minute the true pricelessness of the equine – was written by Caroline Norton. That isn’t ironic. But, that Ms. Norton cheated on her Irish-politician husband with an English, Irish-politician, and her husband ultimately relinquished his “mare” for personal success, most certainly is.
There is also a cultural irony about the bazaar. Joyce’s figuration of Englishmen, working a bazaar in Ireland, is emblematic of what he saw as the bane of popular culture. The silver bracelet that Mangan’s sister “turned…round and round her wrist” (35) is a trinket – a symbol of the conversion of traditional culture to mass culture. This shift occurred, in part, as a result of urbanization. As the demand for factory labor skyrocketed at the height of the Industrial Revolution, large numbers of laborers flocked from peripheral, to central and immediate locations, forming the condensed city structures we see today. With ethnic overlap came cultural diffusion.
The Industrial Revolution provided the necessary framework for the rise of consumerism. At first, the limiting factor in the industrial model was production capacity. There was an immediate demand for large quantities of material goods in the densely populated cities, and it was the factories’ challenge to equalize this demand with production output. Technology colluded with these socio-historical factors to radically invert producer/consumer relations. New and better technology was focused on increasing production capacity – whether directly (through quantity improvement tech.) or indirectly (through quality improvement tech. that allowed for more efficient production and, thus, greater re-investment of capital towards more technology). As production capacity gradually overtook consumer demand, producers faced a crisis: maintain production standards and eliminate the possibility for growth, or reorient technology towards the stimulation of demand. Enter advertising.
The dense, diverse population of the city structure, combined with the novelty of unfamiliar cultural practices, provided a formula that advertisers could use algorithmically to inflate demand. The adoption and subsequent transformation of culture, into product, marks the official start of Mass Culture. As these products were pumped out to the masses, they provided a homogenized version of culture that had been stripped of its real cultural significance (in exactly the same way that the production of image would, later, lead to the Incorporation of Individuality). The masses are then free to construct from the available product alternatives an amalgam of culture to best suit their work ethic, religious preference, leisure time activities, and family values. Welcome to pop culture. This is a continuous cycle. From this point, researchers observe which elements of mass culture are effectively “popular,” and corporations invest in studying how best to exploit the underlying psychological motivations of consumers. But, since popularity defines the status quo, the fresh batch of marketed culture necessarily marginalizes the minority. The homogeneity of culture becomes, simultaneously, increasingly exclusive; and the eulogy intones “Diversity.” Joyce speaks to all of this in three pages. Such is his mastery, his gift, his compression. The last part of my argument is simple. If I have successfully shown how the narrator of Araby is a thoroughly fleshed character, one whose consciousness has been constructed three-dimensionally in relation to cultural, social, and historic factors (which, I believe, I have); and if, within those forces, I have identified a logical and predictable pattern based on the motivations of consumers (ditto); then we should be able to chart the psychological progression of consumerism from the narrator, through Dobbins, to the modern consumer/participant, with a single arch.
The narrator in Araby is already a consumer, and his motivation is Mangan’s sister. More than just a sexual desire, the narrator fells possessive of her. “Every morning [he] lay on the floor in the front parlour watching her door. The blind was pulled down to within an inch of the sash so that I could not be seen” (34). Already, the narrator is a passive, invisible consumer of image. He is a voyeur, like most of Television’s viewership during the golden age of the sit-com – he “observes.” Yet, already, there are demands for recognition, for participation. Thus, he “ran to the hall, seized [his] books and followed her. [He] kept her brown figure always in [his] eye and, when [they] came near the point at which [their] ways diverged, [he] quickened [his] pace and passed her” (34). And, just as the narrators desire leads him to Mangan’s sister, Mangan’s sister’s desire deflects him to the bazaar, to pop culture. They savvy of market researchers accurately identifies sexuality as central to consumer motivation. Over the years those researchers employ better technological practices to ascertain the essence of sexuality and convert it to product. Television eventually offers the perfect compliment for this association. Now, with beauty touted as the spearhead of sexuality, consumers everywhere feel their sexual motivations diverted towards product-outlets by beautiful, captivating women. The prevalence of marketed sexuality is part of what Dobbins experiences as an intimation of interchangeability. The increasing homogeneity of culture plants a seed in the popular consciousness and, eventually, a new essential demand crops: individuality. It is the marketing of individuality that begins to gradually awaken the consumer participant. Suddenly it’s not same standardized product being marketed to every individual, but there are slight, cost effective deviations that allow for product personalization. Out of this personalization we see the true emergence of a demand for participation in the production process.
Granted, this is all drastically oversimplified. Still, the progression can be glimpsed through a direct analysis of the text in relation to causality. And so, we turn again to Sir Isaac Newton for another pearl of wisdom. As he stated in his third Law of Motion: “To every action there is always opposed an equal reaction; the mutual actions of two bodies upon each other are always equal, and directed to contrary parts.”